Where the deduction hides, worked through
#Suppose you staked 10 at odds of 5.00, and your selection now trades at 1.50 live. The fair value of your position is the potential payout re-divided by the current odds: 10 times 5.00 divided by 1.50, about 33.30. A fair cash out would offer that.
The actual offer is computed from live prices that carry the live market's margin, and lands below fair value, typically in the region of 30 in this example. The gap of roughly 8 to 10% is the second application of margin to the same original stake. The exact percentage varies by book and market; the direction never does, because an offer above fair value would be the bookmaker donating money.
Why accepting by default pays twice
#Your original bet already paid one margin when it was struck. Cashing out settles it through a second priced transaction, which pays the margin again. As a routine habit, cash out therefore converts a bettor who pays the margin once per bet into one who pays it twice, and the button's prominence in every betting app is not an accident of design.
The same applies to partial cash out, which sells a fraction of the position at the same discounted price, and to auto cash out, which commits in advance to selling at a trigger. The convenience is real; the price of the convenience is the gap to fair value, every time.
When it can still be reasonable
#Expected value is not the only thing a person may rationally care about. Locking in a sum that matters to you, unwinding a bet you should not have placed, or ending exposure you cannot afford are reasons that live outside the arithmetic, and cash out serves them at a known cost.
The honest framing is the one that survives this whole site: cash out is a service with a fee, reasonable to use knowingly and occasionally, expensive to use reflexively. The fee is computable with the method above, and computing it before pressing is the entire discipline.
Questions, answered
How is a cash-out amount calculated?
In substance: your potential payout divided by the current live odds of your selection gives the fair value of the position, and the offer is that value minus the bookmaker's cut. If an offer roughly matches the fair value you compute, the deduction is small; a large gap is the price of the exit.
Is cashing out ever the right move?
For expected value, almost never: the offer is below fair value by construction. For reasons beyond expected value, securing money that matters, ending exposure you regret, it can be a reasonable purchase, made better by knowing exactly what it costs, which the method on this page gives you.
Why does the app push cash out so visibly?
Because each acceptance is a second margined transaction on a stake that already paid one. A feature that is genuinely popular with users and reliably profitable for the operator gets prominent placement; both halves of that sentence are true at once.
Related